Daily Express - Breaking news, sport and showbiz from the World's Greatest Newspaper
Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 10°C
London
Monday 23rd November 2009 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

UK NEWS

£5BN CHAOS AS LABOUR RETREATS ON ID CARDS

Story Image


U-TURN: Brown has scrapped ID cards

Wednesday July 1,2009

By Macer Hall

GORDON Brown performed his most spectacular U-turn yet yesterday by scrapping Labour’s £5billion compulsory identity card scheme.

His new Home Secretary Alan Johnson announced that no British citizen will ever be forced to carry one.

The massive retreat on the flagship project left the Government’s border control and anti-terrorism strategy in tatters.

It is understood the Government backed down because of the spiralling cost and widespread unpopularity of the plans. Pressure was growing last night for the Government to ditch its ID card scheme altogether.

And ministers were urged to reveal how many millions of taxpayers’ money had been wasted on the abandoned scheme.

Shadow Home Secretary Chris Grayling said: “This decision is symbolic of a Government in chaos.

"They have spent millions on the scheme so far – the Home Secretary thinks it has been a waste and wants to scrap it, but the Prime Minister won’t let him.

ì
This decision is symbolic of a Government in chaos
î

Shadow Home Secretary Chris Grayling

“So we end up with an absurd fudge instead. This is no way to run the country.

“This is a partial retreat. It would be simpler if the Government stopped floundering around and scrapped the scheme once and for all.”

The retreat follows a string of Government U-turns in recent weeks, including Ghurkha settlement rights and holding the Iraq War inquiry in private.

Mr Johnson announced that a trial scheme to force some airport personnel to carry identity cards had been scrapped.

Instead only foreign nationals in the UK will be obliged to have ID cards. And the Government is to press ahead with a “voluntary” ID card for other citizens.

SEARCH UK NEWS for:

Members of the public will be invited to pay £30 to have one of the cards, which will be launched in Greater Manchester by the end of the year.

Lib Dem home affairs spokesman Chris Huhne said: “This is another nail in the coffin for the Government’s illiberal ID cards policy, which will soon be so voluntary that only Home Office mandarins seeking promotion will have them.

"Airport workers did not want to be guinea pigs for this deeply unpopular scheme which has now been reduced to nothing more than a second-rate passport.

“These expensive and intrusive plans should be ditched now.

“The vast amount of money would be far better spent on something that will actually fight crime and terrorism – 10,000 more police on the street.”

And former Shadow Home Secretary David Davis, who quit the Tory frontbench to campaign for civil liberties, said the decision “signalled the final stages of the descent into chaos of the Government’s ID card scheme.”

He added: “Whilst it is welcome that Alan Johnson recognises that the British people will not be compelled to accept this intrusive gimmick, he should also understand that this marks the death knell of this ill-conceived scheme.”

The compulsory ID card plan had been launched under Tony Blair and championed by a string of successive Home Secretaries including David Blunkett, John Reid and Jacqui Smith.

It was proposed in the wake of the 9/11 terror attacks on New York in 2001 and launched in 2003.

Ministers had argued they were vital for combating illegal immigration, terrorism and identity fraud. It was furiously opposed by civil liberty groups and the Tories and Lib Dems.



User Image

OH COME ON.

02.07.09, 11:16am

"compulsory ID card idea because it would show just how many illegal immigrants there are in Britain."

Please tell us all how ID cards would tell us how many Illegals there are in Britain????
The million or so illegals won't have cards. The government don't know who, or where they are.
They haven't got a clue how many thousands are flooding in.
Give us a break.

• Posted by: kayleeReport Comment

User Image

I WILL SAY IT AGAIN!

01.07.09, 9:18pm

Gordon Brown has not been elected as Prime Minister he was not even voted for as Labour leader by his party, he did not put a Labour candidate up against David Davis last year so how can someone with such a disregard for democracy have any further ligitamacy in office?
In addition to the financial mistakes this guy, who spent 10 years at the top of the treasury, has left us with he has also brought words into our vocabluary such as Starlinist Brown, Orwellian and Soviet Britain so he has well passed his sell by date and needs to go to the country TODAY!

• Posted by: DaveyoneReport Comment

User Image

£5BN GIVE OR TAKE THE ODD TRILLION

01.07.09, 6:48pm

Gordon has got us in such a mess he had to cut spending somewhere.He cant admit he got things wrong so is going to quietly dump spending plans.While telling us all that he is spending more.

• Posted by: retiredmaleReport Comment

User Image

HITLER AND BROWN HAVE SO MUCH IN COMMON

01.07.09, 6:02pm

ID CARDS ARE A GREAT IDEA...
...and should be made compulsory for every citizen in the British Isles.
Data safety is an excuse, our name, date of birth, photo and our address in a concealed chip, can be accessed through many other data bases. An ID card could be used to open bank accounts, show at the Doctors and Hospitals when we are admitted, and when we register our children at schools. No ID card, then no facilities. It would stop illegal immigrants, as it does in Europe.
Labour has wasted 5 BILLION POUNDS of our money once again.

• Posted by: Disgruntled


YES - GREAT IDEA - PUT ALL YOU PERSONAL DATA ON ONE NICE CONVENIENT DATA BASE - LET SOME USELESS CIVIL SERVANT LEAVE IT ON A MEMORY STICK OR A LAPTOP - AND THEN SPEND THE REST OF YOUR LIFE TRYING TO PROVE THAT IT WASNT YOU THAT TOOK OUT ALL THOSE LOANS AND RAN UP ALL THOSE DEBTS.

WHY NOT JUST GIVE US ALL A NUMBER - MAYBE TATTOO IT ON OUR ARMS - THEN WHEN WE DIE THAT NICE MR BROWN CAN SEND HIS GOONS TO TAKE OUR GOLD TEETH TO BE MELTED DOWN TO REPLACE THE NATIONS GOLD THAT HE SOLD OFF SO CHEAPLY. GUESS THAT NICE MR HITLER AND MCBROWN HAD A LOT IN COMMON AFTER ALL.

AND DONT FALL FOR THE TWADDLE ABOUT "YOU HAVE NOTHING TO FEAR IF YOU HAVE NOTHING TO HIDE". JUST ASK WHY IF THATS THE CASE MP's ARE STILL BLACKING OUT AND HIDING DETAILS OF THEIR EXPENSE CLAIMS?

• Posted by: Welsh_DragonReport Comment

User Image

LABOUR HAS RETREATED...

01.07.09, 4:56pm

...on this compulsory ID card idea because it would show just how many illegal immigrants there are in Britain.
ID cards are a great idea, all our data is on some computer somewhere anyway, so why not have an official ID that we can show to our Bank to open an account, our Doctor when we need medical care, the Hospital wen we need an operation, and the Schools when we want our children educated. Most of us carry a driving licence anyway, so another card won't make much difference and will allow the Government to know which area need more funds for Hospitals, Schools, Housing etc etc.

• Posted by: DisgruntledReport Comment

User Image

IT WOULD HAVE BEEN THE FINAL INSULT TO THE BRITISH PEOPLE ...

01.07.09, 1:40pm

Our stature would have been less than a piece of plastic...everywhere you go your plastic would have been welcome but you yourself would be second place to a piece of plastic...
Unfortunately thats how Gordon and his nasty ZANULabour party see us... we are just tax fodder !
Every MP should have his/her blood group tattood under their arm in order to facillitate their eventual arrest and trial... !

• Posted by: MoronamidReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Sizzling Britain on heatwave alert

AN OFFICIAL heatwave is set to be declared in the UK as scorching temperatures h...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

Economy is in fastest decline for 50 years

The UK economy saw its sharpest decline in more than half a century in the first...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

Father cut from will in billion-dollar revenge

MICHAEL Jackson has taken revenge for years of childhood abuse by cutting his fa...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year