Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 9°C
London
Saturday 30th August 2008 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

THE IRON LADY DESERVES BETTER TREATMENT

Story Image


IRON LADY: Baroness Thatcher

Tuesday August 26,2008

By Vanessa Feltz

SOME people are more than just ordinary flesh and blood human beings. They are icons, embodying a time, a place, a mood and a philosophy.

They signify more than the rest of us common or garden folk. They are a benchmark, a watch-word, a gold standard.

The rest of us grow old and frail, lose power and faculties and ultimately perish. Icons must be allowed to do none of the above.

Julius Caesar, Jesus Christ, Napoleon, Mahatma Gandhi, Marilyn Monroe, Martin Luther King, Jackie O, John Lennon, Princess Diana and Mother Teresa are preserved in a kind of collective aspic. They remain for ever at the peak of their potency.

It helps that they are all dead and we are spared the spectre of their descent into decrepitude. One such icon, however, is still very much alive. Baroness Thatcher continues to entertain friends and admirers, sitting ramrod straight, her bearing regal, hair elaborately coiffed.

ì
To reduce this iconic figure to an ailing geriatric is an unworthy, even unkind act.
î

A cinema script would have had the Iron Lady collapse on the day her tried and trusted supporters betrayed her and ousted her from office.

Hollywood directors would have ensured that she keeled over, tailored blue suit pristine, patent leather court shoes shining, and died of a broken heart in the House of Commons which pumped her life blood.

Life rarely obligingly emulates art. Mrs Thatcher did no such theatrical thing. What she did do, though, some years later on the advice of her doctors, was to retire from public speaking and making more than fleeting appearances.

SEARCH COLUMNISTS for:

By her own design and the good offices of those who care for her, we neither see nor hear the grocer’s daughter from Grantham whose name alone inspires litanies of loathing or ecstatic eulogies in any Briton over the age of 30.

It is right and fitting that Lady Thatcher, at 82, is living a sequestered life. It has been generally understood, though scarcely mentioned, that her mental acuity, once formidable, isn’t what it was. It was deemed appropriate to maintain her considerable dignity, foster her legacy and preserve her peaceful existence in a quiet, discreet, behind-closed-doors manner.

Until now that is. Her daughter Carol, Queen of the I’m A Celebrity… jungle, has seen fit to puncture her own
mother’s privacy. For the sake of a book, tellingly entitled A Swim-On Part In The Goldfish Bowl, journalist Carol has unleashed an unwelcome torrent of details about her mother’s dementia.

We are told, for example, a fact long considered too achingly poignant to be discussed even in Fleet Street circles. Carol reveals that her mother forgets her beloved husband Denis is dead. Each day brings fresh agony as Denis Thatcher’s widow must be reminded, yet again, of her agonising loss.

Carol peppers the book with scenes of her mother’s dementia. Sometimes Lady Thatcher can “hardly remember the beginning of a sentence by the time she gets to the end”. Sometimes she forgets a newspaper headline she has only just read. Sometimes she “struggles with words and can’t recall what she had for breakfast”.

Such disclosures would be fine and fair from any concerned daughter writing about any mother. The issue here is that Lady Thatcher is not just any mother.

Those of us who heard her “We are a grandmother” speech are in absolutely no doubt of that. Baroness Thatcher is not merely herself. She is far more than the sum of her parts.

She still resides in all that she achieved, all those she aggrieved, all she meant to this country and the indelible mark she left on the rest of the world. To reduce this gigantic figure to an ailing geriatric who forgets whether she had porridge or prunes is an unworthy, even unkind act.

Lady Thatcher deserves more than to have her dementia paraded and picked over while she is still alive to feel – in her lucid moments – the embarrassment.

We deserve more, too. Whatever her motive in contributing to the dismantling of this august image, Carol Thatcher, who admits to a chequered relationship with her mother, should question it.

Let icons be icons. The only appropriate publication date for a book like this should be many years after Lady Thatcher’s State funeral.


User Image

THE NEVER ENDING STORY.............

29.08.08, 12:14pm

Sorry, Vanessa, but I never did buy the traditional story of Mrs. T's downfall.She was not the great infallible icon of modern politics thatmany would have us believe. She did make many mistakes, some of which were insulting to her ministers and even damaging to the nation. She did possess an enormous ego, the kind that females develop - I know better, young man. She did indeed become an embarrassment to many of her colleagues by refusing to listen to advice. Her defeat of the miners did much to inflate her conceit, and this led to her ultimate downfall, not "treachery". We should remember her for being a strong leader when needed, and not as a paragon of all virtues possible.

• Posted by: bluenoteReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Blog Author

Vanessa Feltz

To see all of the stories by this author, click the button below for a complete list.

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year